![]() |
Conference Schedule
Monday
26
th
Tuesday 27th
7) EU-Russia Energy Dialogue Through the Human Security Approach
(Alexander Gusev, Nizhny Novgorod Branch, Russia)
The security of energy supplies have always been an integral part of
national security strategies. Thus, the disruption of energy supplies
can affect national economies as well as people living in this country.
Currently, EU-Russia energy relations are mostly based on the economic
and political approaches and it has led to strong politicizat ion and
securitization. A human security approach requires a broader
understanding of energy security and it helps to achieve de
-politicization of the energy issues. It implies to address new issues
such as climate change and the post –petroleum economy. The traditional
concept of stable and adequate supplies at affordable prices is not
sustainable in the future in either economic or environmental terms.
Thus, there is a need for fundamental changes in the economies of
import dependent states and a refocusing of economic policy in
producing countries.
The paper aims to consider EU-Russia energy relations on the current
stage through the human security approach and to develop practical
recommendations for increasing human energy security. It considers how
to depoliticize energy markets, increase energy efficiency and develop
renewable forms of energy, and how to diversify the economies of energy
suppliers and increase transparency and how to promote a human energy
security.
The added-value of the proposed research is that energy issues are
perceived through the prism of human security approach. For the first
time this approach was introduced by Spanish
Presidency in the EU in 2010 (Helsinki Plus Repo rt). It was formulated
in answer to the propositions of Dmitriy Medvedev on new security
architecture. Then, this approach was discussed by the European
Commission (Human Security and Security Strategy: Institutions and
Policies in a European Perspective) and developed by Shannon D. Beebe
(The Ultimate Weapon is No Weapon, London School of Economics) and Mary
H. Kaldor (A Human Security Doctrine for Europe , LSE) who perceives it
as a new language of security. The idea of human security is able to
properly embrace security situations which are not about defeating a
visible and identifiable enemy, but rather about protecting people from
a much more complex mix of threats.
In our work we are going to use the concept of human security in terms of energy policy.
It means that people’s interest are to be centered focusing on how to
depoliticize energy discourse, make it more transparent, to
redistribute benefits from oil and gas increasing infrastructural
security and consequently human security.
Besides, the EU has several practical examples of human security in the
Lisbon Treaty. The Treaty of Lisbon makes the European Parliament a
stronger lawmaker by bringing over 40 new fields within the
“co-decision” procedure, under which Parliament has equ al rights with
the Council. These areas include energy security as well as
agriculture, immigration, justice and home affairs and other spheres.
Thus, the enhancement of representative democracy is one of the central
elements of the democratization of the European Union in the Treaty of
Lisbon .
A new horizontal social clause in the Treaty of Lisbon also requires
the Union, when it defines and implements its policies, to take account
of employment, social protection and the fight against social
exclusion. The key role of economic services such as public transport,
telecommunications, postal services, gas and electricity supply , is
recognized.
Thus, human security requires a broader understanding of energy
security and it helps tom achieve de-politicization of the energy
issues. It implies to address new issues such as climate change and the
post-petroleum economy. The traditional concept of stable and adequate
supplies at affordable prices is not sustainable in the future in
either economic or environmental terms. Thus, there is a need for
fundamental changes in the economies of import dependent states and a
refocusing of economic policy in producing countries.
This idea of human security is able to properly embrace security
situations which are about protecting people from a much more complex
mix of threats. Moreover, energy security has to incorporate human
security, along with energy diversification, the transparency of oil
revenues, and the universal access to energy.
PANEL 2
8) Philosophy and the emergence of aN energetic education
(Fausto Fraisopi, Albert Ludwigs University, Freiburg, Germany)
In Energy is evidently not a philosophical problem. Nobody, in
continental and analytical Philosophy means that such a fundamental
argument have rights to be admitted in the Field of philosophical
enquiries. Energetic problems determine our life, our ways of
communication, our possibility of production and the ways of human
developments but are not worthy enough to find place in philosophical
discussion? This “nowhere” of philosophy show the limits of a
non-interdisciplinary approach. In opposition to the classical
and contemporary limitative approaches to energetic problems, a
philosophical systemic point of view can integrate these problems to
the fundamental discussion in Philosophy: epistemology, political
philosophy, philosophy of history and philosophy of education. My paper
gives a first approach from the point of view of philosophy (and
complexity theory) to energetic problems and a first topography of the
places that these problems can find in philosophical field. Energy is
everywhere, and thought must fix its “manifestation” by a new system of
thinking.
9) Universality and Emergence in Complex Systems
(Licata I., Giuliani A., Modonesi C.M., Crosignani P., ISEM, ISS, Univ. Parma, INT, Italy )
The feeling of the reaching of a crucial turning point is shared by the
whole spectrum of sciences. The main features of this turning point are
basically identical across different disciplines and can be interpreted
as a re-location of the most relevant level of explanation (and
consequently intervention for more applicative fields) from the
microscopic to the so called mesoscopic level. That is to say that the
interest is shifted from the nature of the basic elements constituting
the system into their mutual interactions. This allows for the
foundation of a ‘general science’ no more constrained into strict
disciplinary barriers.
In the year 2000, in their paper entitled ‘The Middle way’, appeared on
the proceedings of the American academy of science, the Nobel laureate
for physics Robert Laughlin and other eminent scientists set the
scientific agenda for the XXI century. After three centuries in which
the definitive (or at least the most complete) explanation of a natural
phenomenon was identified by the construction of a causative model at
the most microscopic level, scientists discovered that the place where
the ‘most interesting’ things happen were not the ‘basic bricks’ but
the level where the correlations between the fundamental structure and
the global behaviour take place. Using an architectural metaphor, the
authors tell us that we cannot discriminate between a Romanesque and a
gothic cathedral neither at the level of the bricks composition
(microscopic level) nor at the level of the general plan (macroscopic
level), but we can efficiently perform this task taking into
consideration the shape of arches, being the arch the mesoscopic level
linking the microscopic (bricks) and macroscopic (plan) layers.
Far from being a purely philosophical and theoretical proposal, the
article reports an impressive list of ‘mesoscopic approaches’ to
different facts of nature demonstrating the impossibility to tackle
these problems from a classical ‘back to the fundamentals’
approach.
The physicists were used to consider differential equations as the
privileged form of expression for the scientific explanations: these
dates back to the dawn of modern science in which each phenomenon was
considered in terms of ‘motion’. Biologists, especially in these last
four decades, are used to look at the world as a place where some
microscopic agents (proteins, metabolites, hormones) interact by a
‘mutual recognition’ at specific molecular sites. These mutual
recognitions, linearly arranged in subsequent steps give rise to
‘pathways’ that end up with a macroscopic (organism level)
consequence. The above approaches are usually called as
‘reductionist’.
This point is central in shifting of both epistemological and
methodological perspectives. The case of biological sciences is
particularly eloquent because the approaches focused on processes
rather than on structures changed the way we look at natural ‘objects’.
For example, the relationship between genotype (G) and phenotype (P)
based on the linear G -> P map must be considered misleading as well
as the old-fashioned metaphor of genetic material as the ‘blueprint’ of
living beings. As the new conception of the genotype-phenotype
relationship suggested by the stochastic model of biological
development has spread out in last decades, the idea of a biological
system ‘caused’ by its molecular units (e.g. the genes) has lost any
significance. A current effect of this transition is a radical reform
of the neo-Darwinist theories in evolutionary biology and ecology.
An innovative conceptual framework has emerged from another way of
giving birth to our questions, and consequently another way of shaping
and checking our hypotheses about nature. Theoretical issues,
fundamental research and applied strategies can talk each other
bridging gaps between different ways of conceiving natural phenomena: a
strong evidence that it is not just a matter of the ‘speculative’
dimension of reality but of the ‘material’ dimension too. By focusing
on what binds - in statistical terms - genes to populations, to
ecosystems, to landscapes, even to human impact on planetary dynamics ,
we have the possibility to delineate a rational and non-deterministic
nexus to understand the importance of Universality and Emergency in
natural world.
In the mesoscopic approach both these old attitudes of physicists and
biologists are replaced by a ‘phase space’ geometrical approach in
which the system at hand is placed into a multidimensional space
correspondent to its relevant features where it ‘finds its way’ by the
minimization of some general ‘energy’ function. This space is far from
being smooth and continuous, it can be equated to a mountain territory
where peaks (correspondent to energy maxima) go hand in hand with deep
valleys (energy minima) as a matter of fact these representations are
named ‘rugged landscapes’ by scientists. Probably the most studied of
such landscapes are those correspondent to the folding dynamics of
proteins : the axes spanning these landscapes are suitable structural
descriptors (distances between landmark aminoacid residues, contact
matrix descriptors..) and the valleys correspond to stable
configurations of the protein molecule. Other ‘landscapes’ are now
emerging as for cell differentiation and development so allowing for a
sort of biological ‘statistical mechanics’ to be envisaged.
As often is the case in the history of science this kind of
representations are not totally new: thermodynamics made use of very
similar diagrams since decades, anyone knows the so called ‘triple
point’: that specific combination of pressure, volume, temperature (the
axes of the phase space) in which water can simultaneously exist in the
three liquid, gas and solid aggregation phases. An efficient
phase space description of a given system depends heavily upon the
choice of meaningful ‘collective state descriptors’ (such pressure,
temperature and volume for thermodynamics) that could allow us to focus
on the relevant emerging properties of the system at hand without being
lost in a myriad of tiny (and globally not relevant) details.
In the case of ideal gases, in which the interactions between different
particles can be considered as negligible, such collective descriptors
arise as simple statistics over myriads of particles, in the case of
biological entities, where the correlation between the constituent
parts are far from being negligible, we need something different.
The description of phase spaces of complex systems needs to put
emphasis on their correlation structure so pointing to multidimensional
statistics as the main repository of both methods and explanatory
concepts (cluster analysis, principal component analysis,
multidimensional scaling).
In this realm Universality and Emergence becomes the two basic pillars
of modelling efforts. The universal character of the explanations stems
directly from the purely syntactical nature of multidimensional
statistics, e.g. the increasing in mutual correlation between the
variables defining a system is a general (universal) property of any
system when subjected to a stress acting as order parameter, being it a
pine forest exposed to a pollution source or a fibrillating heart [9].
Emergence in turn is directly connected to the ‘data driven’ character
of multidimensional data analysis in which mathematics comes ‘after’
(and not before as in classical differential equation style of
modelling) data collection.
Networks in which the nodes are the basic elements of the system and
the edges their mutual (experimentally computed) correlation are the
most common way in which systems are represented in the mesoscopic
approach. This allows for the simultaneous generation of descriptors at
different scale levels by means of graph theory so we will have global
network descriptors as clustering coefficient, degree distribution,
assortativity, modularity, as well as, single node, single edge
descriptors as the ‘hubness’ or ‘connectiveness’ character of each
single network element.
Even if the consideration of correlated systems will need some non
trivial theoretical efforts in terms of probabilization (small world
nets and power laws as efficacious “devices” to manage both robustness
and flexibility), we must admit (with a great joy) that here we are
dealing with very intuitive and formally simple mathematical methods
that, for the first time after more than one century, hold the promise
to be manageable by scientists trained in different disciplines so
holding promise for a recovery of integration of science after very sad
decades of extreme specialization.
All in all complex systems ask for simple mathematics. They are just
universality and emergence which act as protection laws on the details
of a system and make possible such new kind of simplicity.
10) Beyond the age of coal and oil? Accumulation Treadmill, Urban Dynamics and Roadmaps for Development
(Alfredo Augustoni, University D’Annunzio, Italy)
Walter Benjamin describes with extreme subtility and sociological
imagination the “XIX Century Capital Town”, i.e. the capital town of a
century where industrial production and capitalist economy are emerging
within a world feeding itself by coal: Paris can actually be
considered, from a cultural and political point of view, the capital
town of this century, such as, on the other side, Manchester, vanguard
of “classical” industrial capitalism, such as of all connected
ideologies. In the late XIX century, as Anselm Strauss and Marco
d’Eramo perceive by their completely different analysis, Chicago appear
to be the capital town of the forthcoming century: that means of a
century characterized by the coming of an organizational capitalism, by
the development of great corporations, often with a multinational
organization, from the growth of mass consumptions and an increasing
permeation of economy and politics, with several utopic and critical
ideological elaborations accompanying these phenomena (this brings a
keen observer of her time, Hannah Arendt, to foresee a parallel and
complementary process of accumulation of the economic capital and of
political power). As Manchester anticipates the model of the classic
industrial town, Chicago anticipates several patterns of XX
century (urban sprawl … ). Then, we consider the rise and fall of post
war capitalism, with particular attention to relations between space,
society, technology, environmental and energetic resources, also
towards a critical analysis of concerning scientific production.
11) Green Economy and Green Society
(Giorgio Carlo Cappello, University of Catania, Italy)
A green economy is one that results in improved human well-being and
social equity, while significantly reducing environmental risks and
ecological scarcities - United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP)
(2010). A green economy is a economy or economic development model
based on sustainable development and a knowledge of ecological
economics. Its most distinguishing feature from prior economic regimes
is direct valuation of natural capital and nature's services as having
economics value (see TEEB and Bank of Natural Capital) and a full cost
accounting regime in which costs externalized onto society via
ecosystems are reliably traced back to, and accounted for as
liabilities of, the entity that does the harm or neglects an asset. A
green economics loosely defined is any theory of economics by which an
economy is considered to be component of the ecosystem in which it
resides (after Lynn Margulis). A holistic approach to the subject is
typical, such that economic ideas are commingled with any number of
other subjects, depending on the particular theorist. Proponents of
feminism, postmodernism, the ecology movement, peace movement, Green
politics, green anarchism and anti-globalization movement have used the
term to describe very different ideas, all external to some equally
ill-defined "mainstream" economics. The use of the term is further
ambiguated by the political distinction of Green parties which are
formally organized and claim the capital-G "Green" term as a unique and
distinguishing mark. It is thus preferable to refer to a loose school
of "'green economists"' who generally advocate shifts towards a green
economy, biomimicry and a fuller accounting for biodiversity. (see TEEB
especially for current authoritative international work towards these
goals and Bank of Natural Capital for a layman's presentation of
these.) Some economists view green economics as a branch or subfield of
more established schools. For instance, as classical economics where
the traditional land is generalized to natural capital and has some
attributes in common with labor (providing nature's services to man)
and physical capital (since natural capital assets like rivers directly
substitute for man-made ones such as canals). Or, as Marxist economics
with nature represented as a form of lumpenproletariat, an exploited
base of non-human workers providing surplus value to the human economy.
Or as a branch of neoclassical economics in which the price of life for
developing vs. developed nations is held steady at a ratio reflecting a
balance of power and that of non-human life is very low. An increasing
consensus around the ideas of nature's services, natural capital, full
cost accounting and interspecies ethics could blur distinctions between
the schools and redefine them all as variations of green economics. As
of 2010 the Bretton Woods institutions (notably the World Bank and IMF
(via its Green Fund initiative) responsible for global monetary policy
have stated a clear intention to move towards biodiversity valuation
and a more official and universal biodiversity finance. Taking these
into account targeting not less but radically zero emission and waste
is what is promoted by the Zero Emissions Research and Initiatives.
Karl Burkart defines a green economy as based on six main sector:
• Renewable energy (solar, wind, geothermal, marine including wave, biogas, and fuel cell)
• Green buildings (green retrofits for energy and water efficiency,
residential and commercial assessment; green products and materials,
and LEED construction)
• Clean transportation (alternative fuels, public transit, hybrid and electric vehicles, carsharing and carpooling programs)
• Water management (Water reclamation, greywater and rainwater systems,
low-water landscaping, water purification, stormwater management)
• Waste management (recycling, municipal solid waste salvage,
brownfield land remediation, Superfund cleanup, sustainable packaging)
• Land management (organic agriculture, habitat conservation and
restoration; urban forestry and parks, reforestation and afforestation
and soil stabilization)
Three circles enclosed within one another showing how both economy and
society are subsets of our planetary ecological system. This view is
useful for correcting the misconception, sometimes drawn from the
previous "three pillars" diagram that portions of social and economic
systems can exist independently from the environment.
The Global Citizens Center, led by Kevin Danaher, defines green economy
in terms of a "triple bottom line," an economy concerned with being:
1. Environmentally sustainable, based on the belief that our biosphere
is a closed system with finite resources and a limited capacity for
self-regulation and self-renewal. We depend on the earth’s natural
resources, and therefore we must create an economic system that
respects the integrity of ecosystems and ensures the resilience of life
supporting systems.
2. Socially just, based on the belief that culture and human dignity
are precious resources that, like our natural resources, require
responsible stewardship to avoid their depletion. We must create a
vibrant economic system that ensures all people have access to a decent
standard of living and full opportunities for personal and social
development.
3. Locally rooted, based on the belief that an authentic connection to
place is the essential pre-condition to sustainability and justice. The
Green Economy is a global aggregate of individual communities meeting
the needs of its citizens through the responsible, local production and
exchange of goods and services.
This one aim of this paper to investigate more and more about new
prospective for a green society and any green job. That’s all right now.
12) A Systemic Methodology to Improve Workplace Performance for
Disabled Peoples: a Taxonomy Progressive Systemic Skills
(Magno M., Attainese E., Duca G., Univ. Federico II, GnoSys, Italy)
Many aspects involved in this analysis, are methodologically related
to: psychology, ergonomics, theory of the control, equipment,
juridical, economic and risk in a disability workplace. It has been
possible to take into account those aspects, even if sometimes they are
complex, in the determination of the space of the decisions by the
Systemic. This discipline studies the systems and focus on the model
rather than on the objective and analytic aspects. This one could make
less impervia the understanding of multidimensional and
multidisciplinary phenomena spotting on the finality and meta-finality.
Under these assumptions, subjective feelings of human beings have
started to be processed by a multidimensional objective projective
geometrical approach. In this frame, nearly all must be done. As far as
we know, subjective descriptions have not yet been before correlated
with objective ones in order to link both subjective and objective
descriptions of physical systems related to the disability workplace.
On the basis of ergonomic approach, the definition of a
multidimensional space in its apparent aspects taking into account the
changes in characteristic due to the observers’ positions and the
objectives constrains. In other terms, this research aims at reducing
the apparent incoherence which seems sometimes to exist between
objective and subjective vision of human skills, consequently providing
an empowering tool for any kind of personal characteristic.
Interdisciplinary and multidisciplinary aspect
Merging different discipline: Geometry, Logic, Statistics, Decision
Theory, Multi Utility Theory Decision, physiology, Systemic, Science of
the Communication. Working in risk areas considered up to now as being
excluded from the objective area: in this frame research would aim to
built a bridge between objective and subjective sciences, between
Statistic-Mathematic and Systemic, and would open the way of
quantifying aspects which could just be assessed qualitatively up to
now on one hand and create systemic model on quantified problem on the
other hand.
Benefits for employers and employees cover a wide range of human resources related aspects, such as:
- The company discover its useful positions • The company through this
diagnostic is aware of the technological gap to be achieved by the
integration and the facilitation statute.
- Taxonomy Progressive Systemic Skills
- Cataloguing skills for positive characteristics
- Integration of systemic complex synergies in order to finalize the job
- Clarity of the technical parameters of an addition to the disability as a function of its task and complexity
- Clear exposure of factors complementing the training and professional integration of unskillful
13) Where to look at when health system is talking about an invisible disease? Knowledge
arrangements of life experience and women body
in chronic pain. A psychosocial systemic
response to biomedical reflection
(Pujal Llombart M., Mora Malo E., Maestres Useche C. B., UAB, Spain)
Featuring preliminary conclusions of a survey concerning the
relationship between knowledge arrangements of social life experience
and the contemporary women suffering of chronic pain, our aim in this
paper is to contest the biomedical fibromialgia diagnostic, drawing a
psychosocial hypothesis based on Luhmann’s approaches on “sense
living”. Understanding societies based on knowledge as the “building a
reflected sense of social life”, individual human life experience or
“sense living” must be understood in correspondence, as a structural
coupling engagement in which, “the self, is the psychical dimension of
this relationship. Therefore, “the fatal psycho social triangle
embedding women in chronic pain” (non stopping routinized working
bodies, genderized souls and a strict ruled self or an absence of an
“all encompassing self entity”), can be understood as the structured
mirror glances correspondences of social structures. That is to say, as
the individual side of the structural coupling relationship between
psychic and social systems. In this sense, chronic pain may be
hypothesized in terms of a functional equivalent of the self, in
processing and integrating social differentiation, so to speak,
complexity. Seen in terms of semantics, knowledge arrangements of
social sense, for instances, mechanization, bureaucratization,
genderization, marketization, medicalization, transforms simultaneity
of experience into a temporality one, a redundant and/or a loss of
sense is the matter to be processed either by the self or perhaps the
matter that is been processed by pain in women bodies. Thus, a closer
look to the 40 woman life experience we are currently analyzing, led us
in this paper to focus on those semantic or knowledge arrangements of
life experience implicated in generating the specific problematic they
are dealing with, when managing incompatible and incommensurable
temporalities. For example, temps of equality, gender tradition and
inequality, health care protocols and so on.
Our conclusions in this paper constitute a guide about where to look at
when we are talking about women body in chronic pain? Biomedical
knowledge stopped looking for answers to this question, paradoxically,
when the “fibromialgia” term was coined just to describe something that
cannot be seen, either by its episteme or by its visual technologies
and diagnostic techniques.
14) Dynamic cyclic
structurs, spatial-temporal differentiation and cooperative reciprocity
in the biological and economic systems. Comparative model of the
biological and economic systems.
(Hana Zemanova, University of Wes Bohemia Pilsen, Czech Republic)
Any sustainable system works much like a biological organism. How these
factors are automatically reflected in the organization of biological
systems and economic systems? What laws should copy the model of
a sustainable economic system of biological systems? After much
research, physicists have discovered that a functioning living
organisms carry out work. The Living systems are extremely complex
compared to the organic material, which consists of the rest of the
universe. The Living systems are energy converters that use the
information.
1. work performance
2. converting one form to another job
3. The transfer of energy information.
Human economic systems collapse, as power is transferred to the wrong information. Economists' world revolve money.
The circulation of money can be well compared to the flow of energy in
living systems. In biochemistry textbook even for universal carrier ATP
adenosine triphosphate) using modern parable "energy currency". Money,
however, are not equivalent energy.
Given that the economic system must be connected to the ecosystem
...and the ecosystem input-dependent parameters reflect the
deterioration in the entropy of the ecosystem, there are feedback in
the economic system.
Misery can be considered as absolute. There is a finite optimum speed,
which can be used to transform and resources. Poverty is a threat to
the survival of the system as a whole. Money is a source of energy and
entropy. Vote for real wealth of nations is unreliable (mobilized
energy sources), the gross national product, by the amount of
expenditure on goods and services by different sectors of the economy...
Efficient energy converters, such as the steam engine, or a cell
carrying out photosynthesis, are structurally organized to maximize the
output of useful work - "W " power - output "Q" . Structural
organization " I " provides an information input, which modulates
the information output. The work "W” which results in the reduction of
entropy, "useful" work W must be a function of the information ”I "
input.
Neoclassical economic theory all derived from non-physical parameters /
priorities, technology, income distribution / physical limitations
quietly ignored ...Given that the economic system must be connected to
the ecosystem ...and the ecosystem input-dependent parameters reflect
the deterioration in the entropy of the ecosystem, there are feedbacks
in the economic system.
PANEL 3
15) Project Finance in Energy Industry: an Integrated Approach to Credit Risk Assessment
(Enzo Scannella, University of Palermo, Italy)
Project finance has emerged as a leading way to finance large projects in energy industry.
The basic characteristic of project finance is that lenders loan money
for the development of a project solely based on the specific project’s
risks and future cash flows. This highlights a key feature of project
finance due to the capacity to generate cash flows to ensure the
repayment of loans and adequate returns on equity capital. A revenue
stream from the project large enough is a prerequisite for project
financing.
The paper aims to assess the drivers of credit risk in project finance.
Credit risk is one of the risks to which the project lenders are
exposed. In particular, the proposed paper aims to analyse some
critical issues related to credit risk assessment by lending banks. It
is particularly complex to evaluate credit risk because of large
infrastructure projects in energy industry, large sums of capital
required to finance energy projects, new technologies involved, complex
project agreements, legal and contractual structures, state-level
regulation and tax treatment.
The creditworthiness of the project is a fundamental structural
component that characterizes any project finance transaction. It has a
huge impact not only on borrowing costs, lending contracts, capital
raising, and project feasibility, but also on project marketability,
contractual commitments, structures of investments, guarantees, and
private-public partnerships.
The credit risk assessment of project finance will determine whether
lenders view the project as financeable. Energy projects usually
require a long time period to execute and obtain a return on
investment. This critical aspect requires the identification of
appropriate investors and adequate financial structures of energy
projects..
16) Systems theory’s support for designing a viable energy agenda – The contributes deriving from the Viable Systems Approach
(Polese F., Carrubbo L., University of Cassino, Italy)
Purpose – Energy is a complex issue to deal with, and the paper’s
purpose it to decline a systems theory reflections capable of
interpreting complex phenomena in order to better design and manage
future energy agendas. Achieving an efficient matching of energy demand
and supply needs introducing a market mechanism for the allocation and
pricing of energy resources that especially takes the specific
requirements of energy producers and consumers into account. Moreover,
many other actors ought to be taken into considerations; among these
for certain all world population and future generations. Is seems that
energy is a socio-economic topic that needs to be approached with
network and complexity theories due to the number of interested parties
and the numerous perspectives with which it can be viewed and analyzed.
Furthermore, Smart Energy Grid requires continuous improvement in the
interactions among network elements in order to optimizing resource
allocation, collaborative advantages and cooperative strategies
(Castells, 1996; Gulati, 1998; Capra, 2002), indeed for the systemic
equilibrium within the complex service systems related
the energy services provision.
The paper suggests that the Viable Systems Approach (VSA), a
methodological key based on system theory and relationships, useful for
the interpretation of complex phenomena, might be promising to support
world community discussion upon energy.
VSA, in fact, focuses on the analysis of relationships among
socio-economic actors in search of viable interacting conditions
(Golinelli, 2000, 2005; Golinelli et al., 2001; Barile, 2000), and this
may support the valorisation of all interested parties expectations,
giving voice to all the actors interested in the energy topic.
Methodology/approach – This papers is a conceptual analysis of the
Viable Systems Approach, trying to direct it to the analysis of the
global energy agenda.
Findings – In 2011 we can easily assume that energy management and
sustainable development are two of the most challenging and important
issues we are about to face in the new millennium. Issues that may
affect the length and quality of human life in the world. Despite
their relevance, and the fact that many actors (participants involved
in energy system processes enhancement) are struggling to find shared
politics and strategies to deal with energy production/consumption, as
well as with a sustainable development of human socio-economic
activities, more efforts need to be placed. Researchers, politicians
and opinion leaders, in fact, cannot easily find a solution to such
complex phenomena. Energy is a complex issue due to the multiple actors
involved in its production, transportation, consumption, management. It
is complex for the related continuous technical innovation, for the
balance that needs to be reached among renewable energy sources, for
the shortage of traditional energy sources such as gas and petroleum.
To carry out an efficient plan of activities we have to reach the
elements for a better Energy Agenda. We need a long-term goal to shape
a scientific and policy agenda aimed at smart, sustainable and
inclusive growth. The priority goals in the agenda have to be oriented
to rationalize consumption, diversify the energy portfolio, reduce
emissions of greenhouse gases and increase energy efficiency. Future EU
measures will be implemented through appropriate legislative
instruments, including a legislative proposal encompassing revision of
the existing Energy Services and Combined Heat and Power Directives,
focusing on the establishment and functioning of the internal market,
securing
EU energy supplies, energy efficiency and renewable, reticular
interconnection energy networks. The renewable generations in the grid
could be reachable with the distributed energy storages and advanced
communication network. Accommodating renewable power needs managing the
increased volatility of electricity supply achievable, by implementing
Demand-Side-Management (DSM). DSM seeks to reduce electricity demand or
shift it to times that better suit supply. Consumers can be provided
with the necessary information to better manage their use. Reaching an
active and flexible management requires devices able to communicate in
real time, as smart meters and electronic box, using intelligent
two-way communication between intelligent agents located on the grid.
In order to design and manage future energy agendas the VSA can be
analyzed in order to decline opportunities and constraints expressed by
the involved actors, looking for wise decision making and sustainable
(viable) behavior of producers, consumers, politicians, researchers and
so on. This may be accomplished since the VSA, based upon ten
fundamental concepts (FCs) (Barile and Polese, 2010) introduces the
issues such as: systems; systems hierarchy; reductionism and holism;
systems’ boundaries; autopoiesis, homeostasis, and self-regulation;
structures and systems; Consonance and resonance; system viability;
adaptation; complexity and decision-making. All these seems to fit with
energy and able to support the related system critical deepening.
Research implications – VSA supports energy research and to support
energy decision makers, policy makers and opinion leaders since the
scientific proposal is able to analyze and manage complexity and the
role of many actors (also including ending users), naturally involved
in co creation exchanges characterizing energy production and
consumption. The VSA, being it a scientific proposal based on systems
theory and synthesizing several interdisciplinary contributes, with its
10 Fundamental Concepts represents interesting insights for this
purpose.
Practical implications – The paper helps practitioners to better plan
an energy agenda and business strategy aimed to align energy theory and
practice with real sustainable world characterizing our future
generations.
Originality/value – The paper suggests that increasing complexity of
modern energy system can be analyzed from a managerial perspective for
the creation of value within and among service systems, for a business
as a network of relational service activities.
17) Financial Risk Management: a
systemic approach to the global economic relations. Why complexity
makes periodical financial crisis unavoidable and produces permanent
social risk
(Michele Infante, Jhon Cabot University, Rome, Italy)
The relation within financial system between policymakers,
international institutions and banks are nothing fundamentally new. The
recent financial crisis has strikingly illustrated the
interconnectedness that characterizes the global financial system and
the market as a network of financial agents. However, the financial
institutions over the last 20 years and financial innovations have made
the system much more interconnected, complex and opaque than it was in
the past. If George Simmel stated «money is the spider that spins
society’s web» (The Philosophy of Money, 1986), we can investigate the
money as an immaterial social resource in a systemic approach. Simmel
pointed to the network aspect of money, how financial innovation can
transform the economy and society; and the transformation process as
changes in the complexity, size and nature of economic and societal
networks. In this paper, I want to present the recent advances in
modeling systemic risk using network analysis, and try to apply the
analysis of systemic risk to the financial sectors. While the systemic
stability is a public good, the impact of systemic risk depends very
much on the collective behavior of financial institutions and their
interconnectedness. In some extend, the systemic risk is, generally,
outside the control of each individual institution (banks). In
conclusion, I would provide a framework for strengthening financial
stability, strategies and decisions patterns for the policy-makers. My
goal is not only refining the regulatory and institutional set-up, but
also looking for new analytical tools that help to better identify,
monitor and address sources of systemic risk.
18) Time factor in decision making between tendencies and ambitions
(Barile S., Calabrese M., Iandolo F., University of Rome La Sapienza, Italy)
PREMISE AND PURPOSE
The function of managers is to make decisions, while his role is to
supervise the correct declination of the choices in his specific
context. By analogy, you can think of the hands, whose function is to
grasp and only subsequently carry out specific roles: writing, drawing,
ironing, etc. In order to adequately perform the function of decision
making, the decision makers must have an appropriate information
variety (Barile, 2009). Well-established literature includes several
patterns and techniques that only concern routine, structured,
quantitative and deliberate decisions; scientists have shown little
concern for unstructured decisions, the intuitive and abductive ones.
This paper aims to study these two kinds of decisions: in the first
part we will consider the literature of rational, deductive and
inductive processes, while, in the second one we will analyze
non-rational, intuitive, and abductive decisions. The term rational is
used with reference to those management activities that are essentially
based on the experience and behavior implemented in the past, whilst
irrationality and non-rationality don’t concern the complex government
decisions, that are based on the absence of well-known procedures to
follow. On the base of these assertions and, above all, starting from
the self-evident conception that the past has an influence on the
decision-making process, in what follows we propose to consider the
possibility that future could affect the modus operandi of the
individuals. You could say that our task is to discover the rationality
of what does not respond to rationality (Simon, 1987).
METHODOLOGICAL APPROACH
In order to achieve the ambitious aims of the work, while remaining
strongly anchored to managerial studies, we have to tap into several
disciplines that compose the human knowledge: philosophy (Aristotle,
Cross, Eccles, Hofstadter, Kuhn, Korzybsky, Masullo, Peirce , Popper)
physics (Feynman, Beauregard, Bohm, Wheeler, Wigner), mathematics
(Fantappiè, King, Poincare), cybernetics (Ashby, Wiener) psychology
(Bateson, Damasio, Erickson, Maslow, Mynsky), management (Barile,
Barnard, Beer, Bodganov, Drucker, Golinelli, Fazzi, Kahneman,
Saraceno). The contribution starts from a brief discussion of Chester
Barnard’s theory that, in his book "Functions of the Executive",
distinguishes between logical processes (the conscious thought that
would be expressed in words or other symbols, ie, reasoning) and
non-logical processes (which cannot be expressed in words or by
reasoning that simply express an opinion, a decision. This may be due
either to the fact that processes are unconscious or because they are
so complex and so rapid, often almost instantaneous, that they could
not be analyzed by the person in whose brains they are made). Later, in
Italy, two Maestri linger over this theme, distinguishing between
"government" and "administration" (Fazzi) and between "strategic
decisions" and "operative decisions" (Saraceno). Recent studies, in
viable-system perspective, following the identification of an area of
government and one of administration, permit to better explain the
notions of decision making and problem solving. Then we will analyze
how the notions of supercausality, retrocausality and syntropy could
help to theorize and, therefore, to rationalize interesting new
perspectives, allowing the emergence of a new paradigm on managerial
decisions.
EXPECTED RESULTS
It is generally believed that management requires a high degree of
analytical reasoning, and that great managers are usually professionals
who have dedicated many years to acquire their skills and their
interpretation schemes. However, when a manager is asked on how he can
easily untangle the complex contexts, the answer is that winning
decisions are based on intuition and on the ability to envision a
future, potential scenario. If we accept that there can be the ability
to strategically anticipate an action, generating an abduction, we are
dealing with syntropic phenomena that, in managerial sciences,
represent the embodiment of desire. As an example, think of the will to
launch a new product; before the marketing idea becomes a reasoning, a
strategy, a written plan, it is necessary that this desire is embedded
in the mind of the decision-maker. The fact that the governing body had
planned in some way to launch a new product is due to its ability to
imagine the potential effects related to the introduction of the new
product. Therefore, emphasis is put on the decision-maker’s ability to
prefigure the existence of the firm seen as a viable system through
desire and planning (principle of free will). Prefiguring future, that
certainly becomes difficult at the micro level, at a macro level has
always characterized human action even though it has never been
emphasized in social studies. The will to include new products in a
commercial offer, generates an anticipate causation through all the
actions that are implemented, so that the desire can become a reality;
in other words, you create the basis so that what is desired doesn’t
remain an abstract utopia. The work is intended to provide, after
detailing the notions of supercausality, cyclicity (aiòn),
syntropy and non-linearity (krònos) of time, a procedure that can
overcome firm criticalities, through a response that looks at the past
and future. At the past in order to make a diagnosis of the actions
that led to the existing situation; at the future in order to find a
path that allows you to overcome it. Besides, "we all have our time
machines: those that call us back, called memories, and those that
drive us forward, called dreams" (Jeremy Irons, The Time Machine).
19) Complexity and Decision Making: Implications for Marketing
(Di Nauta P., Polese F. Saviano M., Univ. of Foggia, Cassino, Salerno, Italy)
Purpose – The purpose of the paper is to analyze how marketing approach
is changing and should change as a consequence of the conditions of
growing complexity that characterize decision making contexts. In
particular, focus is on the shift from a traditional dominant logic
structure to emerging -dominant logic systems.
Methodology – Conceptual analysis based on complexity theory and
decision making, attempting to relate these scientific proposals with
new developments in emerging Service paradigm sciences – Service
Dominant Logic, Service Science Management and Engineering –network and
systems theories – Many-to-Many Logic and Viable Systems Approach.
Findings – There are many areas of knowledge that the research
community on Complexity should consider to better understand social
systems in complex contexts, government and management of relationships
and interactions, and marketing processes.
A model of synthesis is devised to represent the emerging marketing
paradigm as a result of a change in perspective from a structure to a
systems approach. On the basis of the ‘big picture’ for the
understanding of social systems behavior in complex contexts, an
innovative viable systems marketing framework is proposed for an
effective management of relationships and interaction governance
approach in complex decision making contexts.
Expected Results – Many contributions have focused on the service
sciences paradigm, network and systems theories, highlighting the
significant integration among these scientific proposals. This paper is
written with the intention to give a further contribution, closely
analyzing complexity and decision making. One of the main expected
results is to draw the attention of both business scholars and
operators on the necessity to change perspective in the marketing
approach. Such, based on the adoption of the systems interpretation
scheme as a general reference framework for the emerging service and
network paradigms, highlighting the relevant implications of an
innovative interpretation of decision making in complexity contexts.
The paper also suggests the integration of the research efforts of
different communities on the basis of common roots in systems thinking.
20) Supercausality, consciousness and managerial decisions
(Sergio Barile, University of Rome La Sapienza, Italy)
Introduction and aim
The fact that past events influence our choices is accepted and shared
in the current epistemological paradigm. But is it correct to assume
that future events may affect the choices we make today?
In the research track of exact sciences, this matter has been debated
for a long time. Physicists John Wheeler and Richard Feynman, with
their “theory of the receiver”, describe a radioactive process as a
“transaction”, in which the emitter and the recipient of the radiation
exchange waves: the emitter sends a wave called “delayed” to the
receiver, and simultaneously the receiver returns a wave called
“anticipated” that, traveling in a negative time direction (that is to
say from future to past), reaches the emitter.
Some philosophers believe that reverse causality (the assumption that
the future can influence the present), is a reasonable opinion provided
that our preconceived ideas of causality are removed. Huw
Price, an Australian philosopher, believes that the current conception
of causality, asymmetric with respect to time, follows from the fact
that it is strongly conditioned by a ‘popular’ knowledge of causality
influenced by established theories of physics, which in turn are built
starting from a universally accepted framework which states that time
travels in one direction only and, therefore, the future cannot
influence the past.
In managerial subjects, and more generally in social sciences, the
problem does not exist. The established paradigm not only admits
anticipated causality, but basically, with the concept of ‘strategy’,
it formalizes the possibility that, within an organization, the
decision maker may be prejudging future scenarios on which to proceed
to make government choices. It is obvious that any foreshadowing, or
more correctly, any strategic framework is to be implemented on the
basis of considerations related to the context in which the planning is
to be developed, and then, to the historicized events and relevant
factors assessed at that time. However, it is indisputable that the
actions taken by management are strongly influenced by the
foreshadowing of the assumptions made. The human decision maker
anticipates in his own mind the future context, and acts according to
it. In particular, no theory of the firm could exist if undocked from
the forecast logic. On the basis of the above mentioned, it becomes
meaningful and important to assess whether there is a possibility,
using the studies and research related to the concept of
“supercausality”, to address the managerial actions through a
methodology of analysis, identification, and implementation of
scenarios that may have greater success potential.
Methodology
The purpose of the work necessarily relate to interdisciplinary
conceptualizations. First, it is necessary to retrieve, albeit in the
form of discourse, the debate in physics (Feynman, Beauregard, Bohm,
Wheeler, Wigner), as in mathematics (Fantappiè, King, Poincare), that
refers to the problems of supercausality, delayed causation,
anticipated potentials, syntropy, time reversal, and so on. Then, it
will be necessary to consider the problems of complex decision making,
and therefore, issues related to the subjective nature of the decision
(Viable Systems Approach - VSA), to the impossibility to act on
established patterns (conditions of non-linearity), and to the
different importance given to rational and emotional inferences on the
basis of problem-solving issues instead of decision making (Bateson,
Damasio, Erickson). It is also essential to address all the matters to
the decision making methodologies in management science. The
consolidated managerial guidance identifies, in the availability of
appropriate information systems, one of the key success factors. The
ability to clearly understand the context (defined as the environment
[structure] filtered by the decision maker) allows to improve the
quality of the decision that can be made by constructing a model able
to envisage the evolutionary dynamics of the context in which the
organization operates, in order to allow the transposition of the
intended goals, in behaviors aiming at their achievement. The set of
analyzed positions and conceptual references allow to formulate
innovative hypotheses for the approach to managerial decisions,
introducing further elements, so far neglected, that should be taken
into account.
Expected results
The objective of this contribution is to possibly redefine the approach
of environment analysis, also in a subjective perspective, as already
argued in the Viable Systems Approach, the introduction of the
constraint conditions, and the causation factors of elements comparable
to “anticipated potentials”. Following more detailed concepts of
back-causation, supercausality and syntropy, and having briefly
examined the canonical structure of a business information system,
resulting in a descriptive and predictive modeling process useful to
the managerial decision, a reconfiguration of the complete decision
making process will be achieved. The work aims at developing, through a
logical deduction criterion, the hypothesis of an operating procedure,
capable of including the “anticipated potentials” resulting from a
perspective purpose, useful to support the decision maker in complex
contexts. Though, ultimate hypotheses have not been provided,
management theorists have noticed the inadequacy of consolidated
procedures for quite some time.
21) Solutions, ICT platforms, services and go-to-market model for technology operators in the energy sector
(Marco Ghisi, Selex – Elsag Datamat- Finmeccanica, Italy – Silvano Cincotti, University of Genova)
Recognizing that global trends are creating flux in traditional Energy
markets, Selex Elsag has launched its own study (developed in
collaboration with the University of Genoa) of macro influences on its
future business base and of ways in which it might respond via the
resources at its disposal.
The macro-external trends to keep in mind include: demographic growth,
an increasingly intensive global carbon economy, urbanization,
mobility, security, information and scarcity of energy, water and
natural resources.
The key question is how these emerging requirements are driving
technology operators in the implementation of innovative solutions for
the customers by making available new technologies and programs that
will reduce energy consumption and improve electrical system performance
From the technology side, this work addresses the need of achieving
higher energy efficiency and consumption reduction through innovative
approach partially based on embedded systems.
The main goal is:
• To enable efficient utilization of energy granting a good level of
perceived comfort and operations by means of embedded intelligence and
integration technologies.
• To Cooperate to optimize energy distribution, minimum of flow transfer and enhance network secure operations
Application relevance focuses on two market sectors: 1. residential and
non-residential buildings and 2. domestic electronics and
appliances, by providing seamless interoperation and exchange of
information among these appliances and an interface to connect the
building as a Cell in the urban network. Therefore it is possible to
provide energy management and optimization beyond “device level
efficiency” and it is realistic to help the energy distribution
provider to maintain secure operation without exploiting more
generation reserve at far sites.
The concept is to achieve the best economical benefits to End User by
efficiently usage of energy and by interacting with the market both to
get as primary scope cost-effective supplies and optimally trade energy
. The secondary scope is the have the capability to interact with smart
grids scenario and be a smart actor as a generation/load point of the
grid.
By Addressing the business aspects and starting from the consideration
that energy is an important asset on which is possible to save money,
the study try to identify different scenarios to offer End User
economic advantages, for example using "flexible" contract; this
contract defines the ability to reduce or increase the consumption for
a certain amount and for a certain period of time and at a certain
price (on the basis of available information - contracts, estimates of
the cost of energy - typical profile of users).
PANEL 4
22) Normative ambiguity and social and economic development: the case of China
(Simone D’Alessandro, G. D'Annunzio University, Italy)
Is China a mature capitalist country or a “primitive commercial
society” in which industries of excellence live side by side with
archaic systems, where competition is unbridled and rights are absent?
This essay uses both a systemic (Luhmann, 1984) and relational (Donati,
1991) approach and reaches the conclusion that the “dragon’s” great
leap arose from:
- a transitional political and economic phase that was supported by a “dual-track” economy;
- a political control of the economy which saw rule by law rather than the rule of law;
- a normative ambiguity/flexibility/tolerance that was in some cases
officially premeditated and at other times was the result of a
community-based and relational reaction of defense against the system;
on yet other occasions it may be considered an “inevitable effect” of
the excessive pace imposed by the economic development.
The situation is not one of strategically governed Legal Tolerance used
to encourage development, but rather a situation of “De-regulation”
that is managed only on occasion and is accompanied by a revving up of
the economy that led to social and environmental imbalances.
China’s normative ambiguity formed the back-drop to a political and
economic system that made the nation’s rebirth possible. In addition to
this ambiguity, there is a view of the world whereby it is the family
and community that acts and where the relationship between the public
and private spheres is reversed compared to western concepts. This
weltanschauung accelerated the country’s economic development by
permitting the socialist and the business economies to work together.
This contrasts with Marramao’s thesis regarding the Westernization of
the world: the facts show that the Chinese model has been
exported from the East to the West. There has been a change in the
relationship between the public and private spheres that has brought a
move towards a hybrid and “analogical” model where the dichotomies
between lib/lab, state/market, democracy/state intervention,
collaboration/competition or merit/cooptation disappear, or fade into
one another to form an “analogical” continuum. In certain areas,
the fast-moving changes and violent evolution of a great a number of
phenomena lead to massive shifts, both as regards figures and people:
it is the pressing on of development that creates voids in the
legal system and not the opposite. Legal Tolerance that is both planned
and managed according to development needs can only really be present
in certain niche sectors, such as biotechnology.
23) Complexity in Co-ordinated Public
Policy Making to Support the Sustainable Growth of Small-Medium
Enterprises in Indonesia: a System Dynamics Approach
(Athor Subroto, University of Indonesia, Indonesia)
Objectives
The current data from the Central Bureau of Statistics of Indonesia
(BPS) regarding the number of small, medium enterprises (SMEs) and
large enterprises (LEs) in Indonesia from year 1999 until 2008 indeed
demonstrated a dynamic behavior is so called ‘overshoot and collapse’.
Policies concerned to the development of SMEs in Indonesia are
undertaken in parallel by some ministerial department (horizontally)
and by different department levels from national to local (vertically).
Complexity is rising while the need of the orchestra to play the same
music in a harmony is rising. Thus, the paper has objectives to discuss
such complexity from the policy cycle point of view in order to
generate a coordinated public policy and to raise some point of policy
levers in order to avoid such overshoot and collapse behavior and to
support a sustainable development of SMEs.
Methodology
System dynamics approach is applied to understand the behavior. Some
relevant variables included in the simulation model are potential
demand, aggregate demand, and quantity of SMEs and LEs. Modular systems
excavated from policy cycle were attached to the generic system that
has generated overshoot and collapse behavior, in order to explore the
complexity of the system and eventually to minimize or even avoid
the rapid decreasing number of SMEs in stock.
Preliminary findings
Simulation conducted in this paper has been able to show some critical
points at which might be useful for the public decision makers to make
their decision more robust and minimizing the unintended result and
feedback. Some of these points are mass media’s role, boundary
spanner’s role and public governance. In particular, from the business
technicality, I underlined the use of a production coordination system
and a financing mechanism for SMEs in order to keep the number of SMEs
to grow instead of “collapse”.
Potential contributions to the literature
This paper re-emphasizes the use of production coordination to support
positive growth number of SMEs especially to prevent collapse after
experiencing overshoot growth and proposes a financing mechanism to
prevent SMEs from the operational failure. This paper also supports the
practice roles of the boundary spanners in the free mass media and
public governance environment.
24) The Rebound Effect in the Light of Network Theory
(Ruzzenenti F., Picciolo F., Basosi R., University of Siena, Italy)
The present paper aims at tackling the Rebound Effect under network
theory's perspective. RE is a phenomenon that has received an
increasing attention in the last decade, as it poses serious threats to
the goal of reducing energy consumption and thereby greenhouse's
emissions, by increasing energy efficiency. The RE theory, so far, has
been widely developed in the filed of energy economics and has its
theoretical ground in the study of price-elasticities. In the canonical
theory, the RE is explained by means of a price mechanism induced by
the introduction of a new technology or process. A more efficient
technology reduces the relative price of the energy service, whereby
its demand raises. Nevertheless, this straightforward explanation has
some drawbacks: are elasticities to be considered constant on the long
run? This apparently marginal question is fundamental in the theory as
it implicitly approach economy as a steady and structurally
unchangeable system. We will here advance a different approach, based
on network theory, to develop new measures of the RE and therefore a
new theoretical framework, upon which explore a different explanation.
It will be illustrated two measures based on the concept of euclidean
embedding of the network and weighted reciprocity, to stress out the
the RE can be interpreted as the result of the a symmetry breaking
process. Measures' results will be evaluated in the light of
appropriate null-models. The need for a different, broader approach is
further suggested by the recognition that energy efficiency and energy
growth are strictly and mutually connected in the vast scope of complex
systems, spanning from ecosystems to societies. Looking back at
evolution there seems to be a sort of thermodynamic law, as was once
envisaged by Alfred Lotka, that tends to foster both energy efficiency
and energy growth. This recognition would appeal for an altogether
different explanation of the RE, based on complex system theories,
rather than price mechanism.
25) Bodies and emotions: sources of biocapitalism
(Vespasiano F., Martini E., University of Sannio, Italy)
We can call it cognitive capitalism, symbolic economy, flexible
accumulation, virtual economy: everyway the actual capitalism pervades
our life and includes our emotions and our leisure inside the
mechanism of production of wealth.
Therefore, a point appears to be central: the industry uses raw
materials as well as our knowledge, experiences, emotions and
aspirations and consequently «the accumulation process is based on and
it takes substance by the faculties of individuals through a reticular
structure of social cooperation. One can say, in essence, that is the
same knowledge to be an expression of the bios» (Fumagalli, 2007: 183).
This paper aims to analyze the new biocapitalism phenomenon as «a
transition phase to production of economic value based on the use of
human beings as a whole, namely the biological, mental, relational and
affective dimensions» (Novelli 2011). In the risk (Beck 2000) and the
«anxiety unmasked» (Luhmann 1988: 33) society the functional
performance of goods and services lose importance and «open space for
new desires and new cognitive experiences of building and sharing of
all possible worlds» (Rullani 2004: 159).
This is the last frontier of postmodern capitalism, «a complex system
(and ideology) that is able to go beyond the exploitation of workers
employed, stable, flexible, or temporary, in the direction of the use
of human treated as a laboratory of advanced technology and luxury
goods at the same time (plastic surgery); as a biological matter to be
patented (genetic engineering); like a vampire use of minds (corporate
shareholder); as explained to symbolically re-qualify in order to
delectare (entertainment and cultural events industry); as a hinge
between sexual objectification and social achievement (the politics of
bodies); as sensory involvement of the consumer, achieved through viral
marketing and advertising strategies, practices of experiential
shopping» (Novelli 2011).
In this scenario, bodies, emotions, ambitions and behavior become
valuable to the industry, which increasingly use them to create objects
of desire, which can hardly resist. In fact, introducing itself as much
more engaging and humanized, the biocapitalism is used by companies as
a new business strategy, offering «products and brands as if they were
real people, and turning to final consumers by offering them a form of
recognition of their identity rather than a good or a service»
(Codeluppi 2008: 7).
To the “shop window” strategy (Ibidem 2007) joins a strategy that
appeals to all organs of the human body: the biocapitalism produces
bio-value not only through the body «in its pure function of employment
tool or outside of the body, increasingly shop-windowing, pursuing
media and consumerist models, but the body as a whole» (Ibidem 2008: 9)
in all its dimensions, i.e. biological, relational and emotional.
26) Brand-Individual Relationship: contextual influences and complexity
(Gianpaolo Basile, University of Salerno, Italy)
Methodology/Approach
The present paper, through a conceptual framework, aims at integrating
the studies about consumption activities and the relationship between
brand and individual/consumer.
Objective of the paper is to show that the relation existing between
the firm and the individual/consumer, created by the product/brand, is
both the cause/medium and the outcome of influences to and from the
respective reference contexts.
Our work tries to fill the literature gaps regarding social
consumption and the network approach, and it is based on
Giddens's sociological theory of 'Structuration' and Golinelli's
managerial Viable System Approach.
Findings
According to Habermas's, Giddens's and Golinelli's theories the
relations between company/brand and individuals are influenced and
influence their respective reference contexts.
In particular Giddens, through a duality structural model cycle,
says that the social player (individual or firm/brand), as a
result of the relation (micro level), changes the interpretative
schemes and social practices within his/her/its reference context (for
the individual: family, social group, reference brand; for the firm:
competitive scenario, financial stakeholders, et al.), creating a
different 'signification' with relation to it. The new signification
affects the context that, in turn, modifies its influence towards the
social player.
Golinelli in his Viable System Approach says that the firm is a system
that must interact with the reference contexts in order to survive.
These points of view show two isomorphic parts represented by the
company/brand and its context, and by the individual and his/her
context, mutually linked via a bidirectional relation.
Practical implications
Communication between social players is mainly aimed at creating
relations in order to satisfy their respective needs. Habermas
says that such behaviour refers to the interaction between at least two
social players capable of language and action who establish a
relationship through either verbal or extraverbal means. The players
seek an agreement to co-ordinate their action plans and their
respective behaviour both within their relations and towards their
reference context.
The company establishes a communicative behaviour aimed at creating a
series of relations based on a common language and/or purpose. The
communicative dynamic existing between company and individual evolves
following a process of mutual interpretation, to be continuously
reviewed, based on the definition of situations likely to be agreed
upon. In communicative dynamic symbolic features are crucial in
creating relations, whose nature should be carefully examined to define
the consequent dynamism within the players' reference contexts.
Contexts, according to Giddens's Structuration Theory, are expression
of different social players, both at micro and macro level, in which
relations are established and reviewed. According to Giddens
biunivocal/dyadic relation processes show the dimension of 'the duality
of structure' as composed of two levels: micro, where we can see the
interaction step between the social players in which they modify their
interpretative schemes, giving 'signification' to a different context
by displaying different beliefs, behaviour and social practices.
The macro level in which, due to different signification, the players
contribute to a contextual exchange, receiving new/different influences
from the reference context to create/maintain the relations. In
management theories contextual influences constantly occur when the
management is forced to adapt to the specific stakeholder's needs, at
micro level, and to the reference contexts (financial system, consumer
system, labor market, et al.), at macro level.
This dynamic, according to Barile, shows that Viable System management
constantly operates in a complex domain. Therefore the company,
when planning both marketing and communication strategies and
tactics, has to take into account the consumer's psycho-social
goals at micro level . If a consensus is reached between the parties as
a result of such communication activity, we will call that social
action. This phenomenon is based on a constant dialogue between company
and consumer and it would allow them to share common ground at macro
level. The individual would gain distinction and/or social
participation, while the company would be able to establish
intersystemic relations with all the relevant contexts (competitors'
system, financial system, suppliers' system, fiscal system, et al) it
has to co-operate with.
On the basis of the above, the firm/brand positioning is affected,
apart from company policies, also by the corporate behaviour of other
brand competitors. This means that the creation and/or maintenance of
micro relations between firm and individuals, involves both the
implementation of brand re-positioning policies by the company
itself and an “induced' re-positioning response by its
competitors. This phenomenon shows an ' instinctive adaptation process'
by which firms re-adapt, also without links-network, either in a direct
or in an induced way, their competitive condition. Which stresses the
importance, for the company, to analyze and respond to the contextual
influences caused by other players' behaviour. Using the tools provided
by the Structuration Model and the Viable System Approach as a
checklist, the framework helps researchers and practitioners to analyse
social elements and structural influences. The contextual influence
analysis could shape strategic thought and tools with relation to
survival in social organizations.
Originality
The paper presents some useful considerations about the evolution of
the relationship between firm/brand and individual and tries to
fill some gaps in the network approach and in studies regarding social
consumption processes.
27) Academic Spin-offs and Technological Innovation Diffusion in Less Successful Areas: a Viable System Perspective
(Levanti G., Palumbo F., University of Palermo, Italy)
This paper aims to analyze the role that academic spin offs play in
enhancing and speeding up the development and transfer of technological
innovation, particularly in less successful areas.
The focus on todays’ knowledge-based economy, has increasingly shown
that innovation is a social process (Gibbons et al, 1994; Chesbrough,
2003 and 2011) rooted on the interactions and knowledge exchanges among
a variety of actors (such as firms, universities, research
organizations, government institutions, and so on). Each of these
actors is endowed with idiosyncratic and specialized sets of resources,
knowledge and capabilities. As a result, the critical determinants of
competitive/innovative advantage rest not only on the innovation
capabilities and activities of a single firm, but also on the
technological knowledge and capabilities that spread across the
environment in which the firm is embedded.
In order to shed light on these (internal and external) determinants of innovation, we integrate:
i) the viable system perspective (Beer, 1972 and 1984; Golinelli, 2010); with
ii) the national innovation systems theory (Freeman, 1987; Lundvall, 1992; Soete, 2007); and
iii) the triple helix model of innovation (Etzkowitz and Leyersdoff, 1999 and 2000).
More in detail, using the holistic approach provided by the viable
system perspective, we see the firm as a viable system consisting of a
collection of operational elements which are held together by a
meta-system. The meta-system and the operational system continuously
interact with the environment and are able to be both adaptive and
proactive towards external stimuli. Accordingly, this approach analyzes
the influence on a single firm exerted by the overlying systemic
entities in the environment (named the supra-systems).
The integration of the viable system perspective with the
aforementioned innovation theories allows to scrutinize the
relationships that link academic spin offs with other actors involved
in the innovation process. By doing so, we underscore the context
conditions and institutions that support academic spin off emergence
and development, as well as those that enhance and speed up the
transfer of technological knowledge from university to industry.
The second part of the paper is aimed to apply the theoretical
framework elaborated earlier to examine the case of the business
incubator established by the University of Palermo, named "Consorzio
Arca", and the academic spin offs it supports. We analyzes this case
study in order to assess the capacity of the depicted theoretical
framework to deliver a satisfactory explanation of the role that
academic spin offs play in enhancing and speeding up the development
and transfer of technological innovation, particularly in less
successful areas.
28) The Energy Policy as the Cultural Issue
(Borrelli D., Gavrila M., Univ. del Salento, Univ. La Sapienza, Italy)
The debate on energy policy is promoted mainly in the scientific,
technological and economic fields. The first aim of this paper is to
focus the energy topic by a cultural point of view: we ‘ll consider
each technical option as an expression of specific view of society, as
well as a pattern of governance, an ideal of communication and public
sphere.
The second aim is to problematize the vexata quaestio of the relation
between structure and culture from an issue very unusual in the
sociology of the knowledge, that is from narratives of the energy
policies.
The nuclear energy technology improves the image of molar, centralized
and militarized society, where the source of everything comes from the
centre to the periphery, at disposal of the expert knowledge and
protected from every external interference. It's the same cultural
scheme that gives rise to the pattern of the waste incineration system
as well as to the pattern of TV broadcasting, with informational
asymmetry between speakers and listeners.
The renewable energy technology, on the contrary, has her frame and
metaphor in the image of the net. It's based upon individual
participation and civic engagement in a molecular form of society.
The World Complexity
Science Academy (WCSA) is a social and cultural no-profit organization
committed to the diffusion of scientific knowledge inspired to the
systemic approach.
The WCSA has also the purpose of promoting the meeting and the
co-operation among the scholars. Consistently with this purpose, WCSA
organizes periodical national and international Conferences and
supervises specific and scientific publications. The WCSA is a meeting
place for scholars from very different disciplines inspired by the
systemic approach.
The WCSA aims at creating a constellation of research projects and
publications to empower a wide horizon and knowledge intensive strategy
to let science successfully cope with the key challenges of our times
concerning economical development, ecology, radical innovation and
biotechnology.
The diffusion of the Systemic Approach is meant both as a peculiar
interdisciplinary paradigm and as an applied toolkit. This approach
strategically faces the main global challenges of our times described
above. WCSA believes the systemic approach is pivotal for intensive and
high added value knowledge sharing on a global scale as we all
entrepreneurs, professionals, scholars and policymakers can cooperate,
as world citizens to facilitate the free circulation of intellectual
and strategic capitals.
Within these assumptions, WCSA is committed and supports:
1) the basic and applied interdisciplinary research within the system
approach believing that this may represent the most effective meeting
place to let different knowledge and disciplines converge towards a
strategic common pattern inspired to the neo-renaissance, “third
culture” shared with the Edge Foundation (www.edge.org) and with the
International Budapest club founded and chaired by Ervin Laszlo.
2) The advancement of global (semantic, methodological, technical etc.)
platforms for the development of a cosmopolitan cognition that would
unify more points of view and would merge basic and applied research in
order to cope with problem solving needs in a context of challenges.
The needs for problem solving ideas couldn’t be fostered with a
traditional local and territorial patterns and identities.
3) The divulgation of the systemic-scientific knowledge and the
scientific information toward educated, but not specialized, targets
(“high divulgation”) assuming the aim to enrich the personal
backgrounds of committed scientists (biotechnologists, engineers,
physics, sociologists, economists, etc.) about global challenges of our
times through appropriate models and systemic- communicational tools
and through high concepts for the diffusion and divulgation of the
knowledge.
4) The promotion of the dialogue and the synergies among public
institutions, business entrepreneurships and social no-profit
organizations to let them provide a more user friendly policymaking for
the scientific world community reducing the influence of vernacular
interests and tactically adopting the motto “think global, act local”.
If you are interested in the WCSA policy, we invite you to suggest your
own projects, research projects and publications in progress of which
you would be glad to receive patronage for free by the WCSA PROJECTS
brand. The patronage of WCSA may be granted both to members and non
members provided that they are inventors and/or developers of high
quality projects connected to the aims and policy of WCSA.
Wishing that the WCSA constellation be of your interest and that it
will be possible to create favourable synergies and collaborations I
offer you my warmest regards.
Prof. Andrea Pitasi
WCSA Scientific Director
HOW TO Join WCSA
WCSA welcomes professors and scholars from all the Countries of the
World and with scientific and/or humanistic field of
studies/research/interest etc.
1) Contact us at join.wcsa@gmail.com. Please specify your reason for
joining WCSA and attach your Curriculum Vitae. Your CV and/or your
e-mail should include all your contact information (e-mail, telephone,
address).
2) The scientific board will assess your request and return a reply
e-mail to you in 2-3 days with further information about the payment of
the membership fee (through PayPal or bank transfer).
It will be possible to Join WCSA as a member directly at the membership desk outside the conference room.
1 All panelists must be members of WCSA.